GardenPulse Guide

How to Choose Between Charcoal, Kettle, Barrel, and Propane Outdoor Grills

Compare four grills outdoor cooking options by cooking style, listed price, fuel type, cooking space, and practical features to choose the right fit for your patio, camping setup, or backyard meals.

Last updated Jul 18

Choosing a grill is mostly a choice between cooking style, space, and how much setup you want around the fire. In grills outdoor cooking, a compact charcoal kettle, a barrel-style charcoal grill, a camping grill with offset-smoker styling, and a large propane cabinet grill all solve different problems. The right pick depends on whether you want charcoal flavor, portable simplicity, more cooking surface, or gas burners with side-cooking flexibility.

Quick take

  • Best lowest listed price: Royal Gourmet CC1830V 30 Barrel Charcoal Grill with Wood-Painted Side Front Tabl, a charcoal barrel design with side and front table features.
  • Best for larger propane cooking: Royal Gourmet 6-Burner BBQ Propane Gas Grill with Sear Burner & Side Burner, with multiple burners and cabinet-style storage.
  • Best simple kettle format: 22 inch Kettle Charcoal Grill BBQ Portable Grill Outdoor Barbecue Cooking ,Black, with wheels, a lid holder, and a freestanding portable design.
  • Best camping-style charcoal setup: 43-inch Charcoal Outdoor BBQ Grill - Portable Camping Grill, Offset Smoker, with two ovens, double grilling nets, a thermometer, and pulley-style movement.

Listed price comparison

The listed prices run from USD 99.55 to USD 469.99, and the lowest listed grill is 79% below the highest listed grill. That is a wide spread, so it helps to decide first whether you want charcoal or propane before comparing features.

ProductListed pricePrice bar
Royal Gourmet CC1830V 30 Barrel Charcoal Grill with Wood-Painted Side Front TablUSD 99.55
43-inch Charcoal Outdoor BBQ Grill - Portable Camping Grill, Offset SmokerUSD 109.99
22 inch Kettle Charcoal Grill BBQ Portable Grill Outdoor Barbecue Cooking ,BlackUSD 123.99
Royal Gourmet 6-Burner BBQ Propane Gas Grill with Sear Burner & Side BurnerUSD 469.99

Decision matrix

If you want...Start with...Why it fitsMain trade-off
A charcoal barrel grill with table spaceRoyal Gourmet CC1830V 30 Barrel Charcoal Grill with Wood-Painted Side Front TablCharcoal cooking system, front table, side table, tool holder, and warming rack are all part of the product description.It is a charcoal grill, so it is not the gas-burner choice in this group.
A gas grill for serving a larger groupRoyal Gourmet 6-Burner BBQ Propane Gas Grill with Sear Burner & Side BurnerIt has five tube burners, a sear burner, a side burner, and a cabinet-style cart frame.It is the highest-priced option in this comparison.
A classic round charcoal layout22 inch Kettle Charcoal Grill BBQ Portable Grill Outdoor Barbecue Cooking ,BlackThe kettle form, wheels, freestanding design, and lid holder keep the setup straightforward.It does not include the side-burner or sear-burner setup of the propane grill.
A camping-oriented charcoal grill with smoker styling43-inch Charcoal Outdoor BBQ Grill - Portable Camping Grill, Offset SmokerThe title points to camping use and offset-smoker style, while the description highlights two ovens and double grilling nets.It is a charcoal camping BBQ rather than a propane cabinet grill.

Concise product notes

Royal Gourmet CC1830V 30 Barrel Charcoal Grill with Wood-Painted Side Front Tabl

This is the strongest place to start if you want a barrel-style charcoal grill at the lowest listed price in the group. The Royal Gourmet CC1830V uses a charcoal cooking system and lists a 627 square inch cooking surface area, with a main smoking area, warming rack, front table, side table, tool holder, and adjustable fire grates in the product description. That combination makes it appealing for backyard meals where prep space beside the grill matters. The limitation is fuel style: this is the charcoal choice, not a propane grill with separate gas burners. It also lists required assembly, so it is not presented as a ready-assembled unit.

43-inch Charcoal Outdoor BBQ Grill - Portable Camping Grill, Offset Smoker

The PayLessHere 43-inch charcoal grill is a good match for shoppers drawn to a camping BBQ format with offset-smoker styling. Its description emphasizes multiple barbecue modes, two ovens, double grilling nets, a built-in visible thermometer, an air door, chimney airflow control, and a bottom pulley design for easier movement. Those details make it more flexible than a bare charcoal grate when you want to manage airflow and monitor heat. The trade-off is that the title and listed type keep it firmly in charcoal camping territory. If your priority is gas ignition, a cabinet cart, or a side burner, the Royal Gourmet propane model is the more direct fit.

22 inch Kettle Charcoal Grill BBQ Portable Grill Outdoor Barbecue Cooking ,Black

The Captiva Designs kettle grill fits shoppers who want a familiar round charcoal grill shape without moving into a barrel or cabinet-style design. It lists a 22 inch grill size, black color, charcoal fuel type, stainless steel griddle material, wheels, a freestanding build, a lid holder, and portable features. The 362 sq. in cooking area length gives it a clear size reference for comparing against the larger Royal Gourmet charcoal barrel grill. Its limitation is built into the format: a kettle grill is simpler than the propane model with a sear burner and side burner, and it does not describe the two-oven setup found on the 43-inch camping grill.

Royal Gourmet 6-Burner BBQ Propane Gas Grill with Sear Burner & Side Burner

The Royal Gourmet 6-burner propane grill is the most feature-packed choice here for gas cooking. It lists 74,000 BTU total output, five tube burners, a sear burner, a side burner, one-touch electronic ignition, enameled wire cooking grates, flame tamers, a removable grease tray, a grease cup, LP cylinder storage, and swivel casters with brakes. The cooking space is listed at 774 sq. in, with wording that it can cook up to 34 burgers at once and serve 8-10 guests. The limitation is cost and scale: at the top of this price spread, it makes the most sense only if the propane burner setup is the main reason you are buying.

Final recommendation

For most shoppers comparing these four, the first split should be charcoal vs. propane. If you want gas burners, the Royal Gourmet 6-Burner BBQ Propane Gas Grill with Sear Burner & Side Burner is the clear fit because the title and features center on propane, a sear burner, a side burner, and 74,000 BTU output. It is also the highest listed price, so it is best justified by the larger cooking space and burner layout.

If you want charcoal and the lowest listed price, choose the Royal Gourmet CC1830V 30 Barrel Charcoal Grill with Wood-Painted Side Front Tabl. It combines the lowest position in the price range with a barrel shape, charcoal cooking system, warming rack, and table features.

Choose the 22 inch Kettle Charcoal Grill BBQ Portable Grill Outdoor Barbecue Cooking ,Black if you prefer a compact kettle layout with wheels and a lid holder. Choose the 43-inch Charcoal Outdoor BBQ Grill - Portable Camping Grill, Offset Smoker if the camping BBQ title, offset-smoker styling, two ovens, double grilling nets, and thermometer are more important than the classic kettle form.

Products in this article